Blocking HI Roundabout Protest Legal, Says Minister Pigai

5 hours ago 25
Human Rights Minister Natalius Pigai when met at the Parliament Complex, June 17, 2026. Tempo/Andi Adam Faturahman

TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - Human Rights Minister Natalius Pigai stated that the roadblock set up by joint military-police forces against students marching in the "Menuju Indonesia Bangkrut" (towards Indonesia's bankruptcy) rally complied with existing regulations.

He explained that the interception was carried out to prevent students from demonstrating in the Hotel Indonesia (HI) Roundabout area, in line with Jakarta Governor Regulation Number 232 Year 2015 concerning the Management of Public Expression in Public Spaces.

"There are clear regulations regarding demonstrations in business zones and traffic areas. There were no violations by the authorities involved in the blockade," Pigai said at the Parliament Complex on Wednesday, June 17, 2026.

He emphasized that he supports the students' right to express their opinions in public. However, he noted that during such activities, it is equally important to acknowledge the legal allowances for authorities to impose specific restrictions.

According to Pigai, within the framework of human rights, the Siracusa Principles authorize authorities to implement restrictions based on certain considerations, such as protecting the HI Roundabout area, which is an epicenter for business and traffic.

Under this principle, he said, both the demonstrators and the on-duty authorities share a mutual responsibility to respect civil rights, which includes maintaining public order.

"So, it is in accordance with the Siracusa human rights principles that demonstrations cannot be held at this specific location, but only at another point, considering traffic congestion or other strategic factors. Nevertheless, I appreciate the students for continually voicing the rights of the community," the former National Commission on Human Rights (Komnas HAM) commissioner added.

The Siracusa Principles govern the limitation and derogation of human rights provisions within the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. This framework dictates that while freedom of expression is restricted from being used to incite war, spread hatred, or discriminate based on religion, ethnicity, and race, it must also not compromise national order.

However, in their implementation, the Siracusa Principles stipulate that any restrictions placed on civil and political matters must strictly be non-discriminatory; furthermore, such limitations must only be applied when responding to an urgent social need for legitimate purposes, such as protecting national security, public safety, public order, public health, public morals, or the rights and freedoms of others.

Students participating in the "Menuju Indonesia Bangkrut" rally found themselves blocked by joint military-police (TNI-Polri) forces as they attempted to make their way toward the demonstration site at the HI Roundabout.

Chairperson of the University of Indonesia Student Executive Board (BEM UI) Yatalathof Ma'shum Imawan, who took part in the march, stated that authorities began intercepting the crowd the moment they arrived in the Semanggi area. The blockade line then moved further up in front of the Thamrin Nine Building.

The Head of the Public Relations Division of the Jakarta Metropolitan Regional Police, Commissioner Budi Hermanto, clarified the reasoning behind the police decision to deny the students access to the HI Roundabout.

He stated that according to Jakarta Governor Regulation Number 232 Year 2015 concerning the Management of Public Expression in Public Spaces, the HI Roundabout area is explicitly barred from serving as a demonstration site.

He pointed out that the entire area spanning from the Senayan Roundabout, Semanggi, and the HI Roundabout, all the way to the Arjuna Wijaya Horse Statue area in Central Jakarta, serves as the city's primary artery for business and transit, meaning any protest there would trigger severe gridlock. "If the main roads in Jakarta become congested, then other daily community activities will be disrupted. So, that is what we need to convey to the public and our younger student counterparts," Budi said at the HI Roundabout area.

Hendrik Yaputra contributed to this article.

Read: UI Student Journalists Report Harassment After Protest Coverage

Click here to get the latest news updates from Tempo on Google News


Bandung Students Protest for Third Time; Here Are the Demands

5 jam lalu

Bandung Students Protest for Third Time; Here Are the Demands

Students from 23 campuses across West Java staged a third protest before the DPRD Bandung today, June 17, 2026. What are their demands?


Today's Top 3 News: Why Amnesty Opposes the Military's Role in Securing Protests

7 jam lalu

Today's Top 3 News: Why Amnesty Opposes the Military's Role in Securing Protests

Here is the list of the top 3 news on Tempo English today.


3 Demands Raised by Indonesian Women's Alliance in Jakarta Protest

10 jam lalu

3 Demands Raised by Indonesian Women's Alliance in Jakarta Protest

The Women's Alliance of Indonesia will hold a protest at Jakarta's State Palace on Thursday, June 18, 2026, joined by at least 90 women's groups.


Why Amnesty Opposes the Military's Role in Securing Protests

13 jam lalu

Why Amnesty Opposes the Military's Role in Securing Protests

Amnesty International Indonesia's Executive Director, Usman Hamid, criticizes the security measures involving the military and civil organizations in demonstrations. What are his reasons?


Why Women's Alliance Is Bringing Kitchen Utensils to Anti-MBG Protest

14 jam lalu

Why Women's Alliance Is Bringing Kitchen Utensils to Anti-MBG Protest

The Indonesian Women's Alliance plans a symbolic protest demanding lower food prices and a suspension of the Free Nutritious Meals (MBG) program.


Indonesian Women's Alliance to Hold Anti-MBG Protest Tomorrow

15 jam lalu

Indonesian Women's Alliance to Hold Anti-MBG Protest Tomorrow

Alliance of Women in Indonesia demand temporary halt to the free nutritious meal program (MBG) to evaluate overall Prabowo's flagship project.


Students to Hold 'Indonesia Emergency' Protest in West Java Today

17 jam lalu

Students to Hold 'Indonesia Emergency' Protest in West Java Today

The Students' Executive Body of Indonesia (BEM SI) is set to hold a demonstration under the banner of 'Indonesia Emergency'.


UI Student Journalists Report Harassment After Protest Coverage

18 jam lalu

UI Student Journalists Report Harassment After Protest Coverage

Several student journalists University of Indonesia (UI) were reportedly being harassed after covering student protests on Friday, June 12, 2026.


Today's Top 3 News: Will a Weaker Rupiah Help Indonesia's Economy Grow?

1 hari lalu

Today's Top 3 News: Will a Weaker Rupiah Help Indonesia's Economy Grow?

Here is the list of the top 3 news on Tempo English today.


Palace: No Deal Reached Between VP Gibran and Student Protesters

1 hari lalu

Palace: No Deal Reached Between VP Gibran and Student Protesters

"There was no agreement. The Vice President only listened," says ofiicial.


Read Entire Article
Pemilu | Tempo | |