TEMPO.CO, Jakarta – The 2026 World Cup semifinal between England and Argentina is expected to be more than just a battle for a place in the final. When the two sides meet at Atlanta Stadium, United States, on Thursday, July 16, they will bring decades of rivalry, controversy, and unfinished business onto the pitch.
Among the classic World Cup rivalries, few have produced as much tension as the meetings between the Three Lions and the Albiceleste. Their encounters have repeatedly gone beyond football, shaped by disputed goals, heated confrontations, political history, and moments that remain etched in World Cup folklore.
The rivalry stretches back to 1951, when the two teams first met in a friendly match in London. Since then, England and Argentina have faced each other 15 times, with England winning six matches and Argentina two.
They have also met five times at the World Cup, with England claiming three victories and Argentina winning twice.
A Rivalry Built on Controversy
The first World Cup meeting between the two teams came in 1962, when England defeated Argentina 3-1 in the quarterfinals. But the rivalry truly intensified four years later at the 1966 World Cup.
In that quarterfinal clash, England advanced with a 1-0 victory thanks to Geoff Hurst's goal. Argentina disputed the goal, claiming it should have been ruled offside.
The match was also marked by physical clashes, with Argentina captain Antonio Rattin being sent off. After the game, England manager Sir Alf Ramsey controversially described Argentina's style of play as "animalistic" and unsporting.
The heated encounter became one of the incidents that pushed FIFA to introduce yellow and red cards at future World Cups.
The Maradona Drama and a Rivalry Beyond Football
Twenty years later, the two teams met again in the 1986 World Cup quarterfinals, just four years after the Falklands War, a conflict between Argentina and the United Kingdom over the disputed islands.
That match produced two of the most famous goals in World Cup history from Diego Maradona: the "Hand of God" goal and the "Goal of the Century."
While Maradona's second goal was celebrated worldwide as a masterpiece, England felt betrayed by the first, which was scored illegally with his hand. England goalkeeper Peter Shilton later said he never accepted Maradona's apology.
The rivalry continued at the 1998 World Cup, when England were eliminated on penalties after a dramatic 2-2 draw in the round of 16. England believed Diego Simeone had exaggerated contact that led to David Beckham's red card.
Four years later, Beckham became the hero as his penalty secured England's 1-0 victory over Argentina in the 2002 World Cup group stage.
Their last World Cup meeting remains that match. Their most recent encounter overall came in a 2005 friendly in Switzerland, where England won 3-2.
A Semifinal With Bigger Stakes
After 21 years, England and Argentina will meet again, this time with a World Cup final place at stake.
The match carries enormous significance for both teams.
Argentina are chasing history. A victory would keep alive their ambition of becoming only the third nation after Brazil and Italy to win back-to-back World Cup titles. It would also provide the perfect final chapter for Lionel Messi's legendary international career.
England, meanwhile, are seeking to end a 60-year wait since their only World Cup triumph in 1966. The Three Lions have reached the semifinal stage three times but have made the final only once, when they lifted the trophy on home soil.
The drama surrounding this semifinal is also fueled by the doubts both teams faced before reaching this stage.
Unlike France and Spain, who entered the semifinal after conceding only one goal each, Argentina and England had each conceded four goals before the last four.
Argentina had also avoided top-10 opponents throughout the tournament, with Switzerland (14th) and Egypt (24th) being their highest-ranked opponents before the semifinal.
On paper, England's head-to-head record and more difficult path suggest they could have the advantage. But history offers a warning: Argentina have never lost a World Cup semifinal, winning three of their previous six appearances at this stage, including their championship campaigns in 1978, 1986, and 2022.
Tuchel vs Messi: The Ultimate Test
England arrive with renewed confidence under Thomas Tuchel.
Unlike their 2018 semifinal run under Gareth Southgate, when they suffered a group-stage defeat, England reached this stage unbeaten. Tuchel has built a more disciplined team based on structure and teamwork.
The Three Lions may not be as spectacular as France and Spain or as prolific as Argentina, who have scored 17 goals, but their organization could make them dangerous.
England's 4-2-3-1 system has helped Declan Rice and Elliot Anderson control midfield, while Harry Kane remains the main attacking threat.
For Argentina, the biggest question remains Messi.
The semifinal will be Messi's first meeting with England at international level, although he has played 205 matches for Argentina. Still, his experience against English clubs remains significant, with 36 previous encounters and a 53 percent win rate.
Messi has also been decisive throughout the tournament, creating 33 chances and scoring eight goals before the semifinal, ahead of Kane's six goals from 22 chances.
If England can contain Messi as they did Erling Haaland in their quarterfinal victory over Norway, Tuchel could move closer to matching Sir Alf Ramsey's 1966 achievement.
But stopping Messi is a different challenge.
A victory would also put Argentina coach Lionel Scaloni closer to joining Vittorio Pozzo as the only coaches to win two World Cups.
For England and Argentina, this semifinal promises another unforgettable chapter in one of football's greatest rivalries.
Click here to get the latest news updates from Tempo on Google News
