4 days ago
5
November 12, 2024 | 05:02 pm
TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - Established to provide an opportunity to obtain loans, Danantara could sink Indonesia into a debt quagmire. Risk mitigation is key.
The establishment of the Danantara Investment Management Agency by President Prabowo Subianto has given rise to a question: will state companies hived off from the State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) Ministry and then grouped under this new institution become more professional, transparent and free of political intervention? Or is there a threat of a new danger: by being too aggressive in seeking funds from mortgaging assets, Danantara could sink Indonesia into a debt quagmire.
Despite the claims that it will be similar to Temasek, the global investment company owned by Singapore, Danantara is actually more like Khazanah, the Malaysian investment body. While Temasek invests surplus government funds to generate substantial returns, Khazanah uses assets as collateral to seek investors. In other words, Danantara is an investment seeker like Khazanah, not a capital injector like Temasek.
In the first phase, Danantara will oversee seven of the largest state companies, namely Mandiri, BRI, PLN, Pertamina, BNI, Telkom and MIND ID, with total assets of Rp8,886 trillion. With the addition of the Indonesian Investment Authority, the state-owned investment management body, Danantara’s assets will be total Rp9,046 trillion. Subsequently, other state-owned enterprises and companies with special missions under the Finance Ministry, such as Sarana Multi Infrastruktur, will also come under Danantara, with the result that its total assets will exceed Rp15 quadrillion, or around 75 percent of Indonesia’s gross domestic product (GDP).
The government needs loans to pay for development. But the new loans in the State Budget will not be sufficient to cover the shortfall in the government’s budget, which has to be used to pay the principal and interest on existing and larger debts. Seeking investors by offering assets owned by companies under Danantara as collateral seems to be an instant solution.
But there is a potential danger: when there is an urgent need for funds, Danantara’s aggressive use of these assets to seek funding will invite potential disaster. Taking on loans exceeding the value of assets, in other words, being over-leveraged, carries a huge risk. This over-leveraging will reduce cash flow because some revenue will have to be used to pay interest. If the value of assets falls or revenue is insufficient, this over-leveraging could make it difficult to repay debts—which could in turn trigger the sale of assets, including by selling at a loss.
The establishment of Danantara is also an indirect way for the government to pay for flagship programs without going through the Finance Ministry. As it is directly under the authority of the president, Danantara could potentially be mobilized to cover the costs of programs or perhaps the political interests of Prabowo.
Therefore, seen from the macro economy perspective, Danantara could become a boomerang for Indonesia. So far, calculations of Indonesia’s debt ratio to GDP have only considered government debt, and not the debts of SOEs. This type of calculation could give rise to a false sense of security because it gives the impression that the debt ratio is still below 40 percent. However, if they are taken together, the debt ratio of the government and SOEs has already exceeded the safe level. From this perspective, Danantara is like papering over the cracks.
Danantara will have to simultaneously use a micro and macro approach. The Finance Ministry must be involved to a significant extent, especially in regard to risk mitigation. The bad practices that have been used by the SOEs Ministry, such as using government companies as cash cows, must be stopped. Handing out jobs in return for political favors will only give rise to mismanagement and waste.
Without careful risk mitigation, Danantara will only bring us to the verge of bankruptcy.
Prabowo Asks Erick Thohir to Continue SOEs Reform
3 hari lalu
Erick Thohir says this program has been running since he was a minister in President Jokowi's era.
8 Most Expensive Cities in Canada
4 hari lalu
Despite having a top-ranking GDP in recent years, these most expensive cities in Canada still hinder citizens from having a better quality of life.
Sri Mulyani Says October's Fiscal Deficit of Rp309tn Remains Low
4 hari lalu
Indonesian Finance Minister Sri Mulyani has reported that the state budget recorded a deficit of Rp309.2 trillion by the end of October 2024.
7 Richest Countries in Asia, Oil Producing Nations Dominate
4 hari lalu
Asian countries have been showing numerous advancement trends. See the richest countries in Asia by GDP here.
Disarray in Peatland Areas
5 hari lalu
The food estate project in Central Kalimantan turned into an oil palm plantation. The government failed to learn from the mistakes of the past.
Palace: Prabowo Won't Rush the Launch of Superholding Danantara
5 hari lalu
The government of Prabowo Subianto intends to establish Danantara, expecting it as a major investment manager in Indonesia.
The Vicious Circle of Judicial Mafia
7 hari lalu
With the Supreme Court's judicial mafia, when one branch is lopped off, another 10 grow in its place. It needs to be comprehensively cleaned up.
Indonesia's Economic Growth Slows Down to 4.95% in Q3 of 2024, BPS Says
7 hari lalu
Economic growth next year is also expected to stagnate at 5.1 percent.
SOEs Minister Erick Thohir Plans to Merge Pelni and ASDP into Pelindo
7 hari lalu
Indonesia's Minister of State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) Erick Thohir plans to merge PT Pelni with PT ASDP into PT Pelabuhan Indonesia (Pelindo)
1998 Student Kidnapping is Human Rights Violation
10 hari lalu
Prabowo Subianto is hoping to erase his sins in relation to the 1998 kidnappings. Gross human rights violations will not be a priority.
