Constitutional Court Rules on Rerun Elections for Empty Box Victories

2 days ago 5

November 14, 2024 | 01:22 pm

TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - The Constitutional Court has issued a ruling in Case Number 126/PUU-XXII/2024 which challenged Article 54D paragraph 3 of Law Number 10 of 2016 concerning Regional Head Elections (Pilkada). Chief Justice MK Suhartoyo said this article contradicted the 1945 Constitution and lacked a clear provision for rerun elections.

In its decision, the Court mandates a rerun election if a blank ballot or an empty box emerges as the winner or secures the highest number of votes among the competing candidate pairs.

“The subsequent election must be conducted within a maximum of one year from the date of the initial vote. The elected regional head/deputy regional head resulting from this rerun election will serve until the inauguration of the regional head and deputy regional head elected in the following simultaneous election, provided it does not exceed a five-year term from the date of inauguration,” Suhartoyo explained during the verdict pronouncement on Thursday, November 14, 2024.

On Friday, November 8, the General Election Commission (KPU) proposed that regions with blank ballot victories be led by acting officials. For the 2024 regional elections, KPU Chair Mochammad Afifuddin later confirmed that a rerun election would be held the following year, likely in September 2025. 

Afif claimed that the matter had been discussed with the House of Representatives (DPR) Commission overseeing government affairs. He also indicated that discussions regarding the rerun election's stages would commence after the conclusion of the 2024 regional election contestation process.

Ahmad Doli Kurnia Tandjung, former Chair of the DPR Commission on Government Affairs, expressed agreement with the KPU's proposal to schedule the rerun election on September 25, 2025. Doli emphasized that the Commission had previously determined that a rerun election resulting from a blank ballot victory should not exceed one year from the initial vote.

In the 2024 regional elections, the KPU recorded 37 regions with only one candidate. The Association for Elections and Democracy (Perludem) noted that this figure represents the highest number of single-candidate local elections since the 2015 Regional Elections.

Alfitria Neti contributed to the writing of this article.

Editor's Choice: Regional Election: Probe on Prabowo's Alleged Candidate Endorsement Concludes Next Week

Click here to get the latest news updates from Tempo on Google News



Jokowi to Join Ahmad Luthfi-Taj Yasin's Campaign Events in Several Regions

50 detik lalu

Jokowi to Join Ahmad Luthfi-Taj Yasin's Campaign Events in Several Regions

Jokowi's involvement is expected to bolster the electability of the candidate pair in the Central Java regional election.


Regional Election: Probe on Prabowo's Alleged Candidate Endorsement Concludes Next Week

39 menit lalu

Regional Election: Probe on Prabowo's Alleged Candidate Endorsement Concludes Next Week

A video shows Prabowo encouraging people to vote for the Central Java gubernatorial running pair.


26 Years of Semanggi I Tragedy: KontraS Decries Stagnant Legal Process

1 jam lalu

26 Years of Semanggi I Tragedy: KontraS Decries Stagnant Legal Process

KontraS said the case files have been repeatedly transferred between Komnas HAM and the Attorney General's Office without any significant progress.


DPR Responds to BPJS Kesehatan's Premium Increase Proposal to Prabowo

1 jam lalu

DPR Responds to BPJS Kesehatan's Premium Increase Proposal to Prabowo

BPJS Kesehatan proposes to Indonesian President Prabowo to increase premiums due to the risk of default that companies could face in 2026.


Shigeru Ishiba Reelected as Japan's PM in First Runoff Vote in Three Decades

2 hari lalu

Shigeru Ishiba Reelected as Japan's PM in First Runoff Vote in Three Decades

Shigeru Ishiba's rival in the Japanese parliament election, Yuichiro Tamaki, is hit by infidelity accusations


Bawaslu Probes Prabowo's Alleged Endorsement of Central Java Election Candidate

3 hari lalu

Bawaslu Probes Prabowo's Alleged Endorsement of Central Java Election Candidate

Bawaslu is investigating a short video clip of President Prabowo endorsing the Ahmad Luthfi-Taj Yasin ticket in Central Java gubernatorial election.


Three Killed, 66 Injured in Mozambique Opposition Protest, Hospital Says

5 hari lalu

Three Killed, 66 Injured in Mozambique Opposition Protest, Hospital Says

Thursday's protests were the biggest Mozambique has ever seen against Frelimo, the party that has ruled the southern African state since 1975.


Simultaneous Regional Elections on November 27 to Be a National Holiday

5 hari lalu

Simultaneous Regional Elections on November 27 to Be a National Holiday

The government has announced that November 27, 2024, the voting day of the Simultaneous Regional Elections will be designated as a national holiday.


5 U.S. Presidents Who Failed to Win Re-Election

6 hari lalu

5 U.S. Presidents Who Failed to Win Re-Election

While many U.S. presidents have successfully secured a second term, others have not been as fortunate. Here is a list of 5 of them.


KPU: 203 Million Voters Registered for Regional Elections

6 hari lalu

KPU: 203 Million Voters Registered for Regional Elections

KPU states that 203 million voters are spread across 435,296 polling stations.


Read Entire Article
Pemilu | Tempo | |