2 hours ago
8
January 22, 2025 | 05:15 pm
TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - U.S. President Donald Trump's executive order to restore access to TikTok has created a thicket of new legal questions for the short-video platform, along with new tensions between the White House, members of Congress who want the platform banned, and tech companies caught in the middle.
Legal experts said despite Trump's order, service providers and app distributors such as Google (GOOGL.O) and Apple (AAPL.O) still face major uncertainty and potential massive financial liability for defying a law that banned TikTok in the United States unless Chinese parent ByteDance divested the company by Jan. 19.
TikTok remained unavailable to download on Apple and Android devices in the United States early Tuesday afternoon, after Trump signed an executive order on Monday, January 20, 2025, seeking to pause the U.S. ban as one of his first acts as president.
The order directs the U.S. Justice Department to delay for 75 days any enforcement of the divestment law, passed by Congress last year.
Trump also directed the U.S. attorney general to send a letter to service providers such as app store hosts, saying there has been no prior violation of the law, and would be no liability during the review period.
University of Minnesota Law School professor Alan Rozenshtein said in a post at the national security publication Lawfare on Tuesday, January 21, that the 75-day enforcement delay in Trump's executive order "offers minimal security," however, since courts do not see such promises as binding.
"Trump could change his mind at any time or selectively enforce against companies that fall from political favor," Rozenshtein wrote.
Google declined to comment, and Apple did not immediately respond to a request for one.
The divestment law, which Congress passed with overwhelming bipartisan support amid national security concerns over Chinese influence, was signed by President Joe Biden and upheld by a unanimous U.S. Supreme Court on Jan. 17.
It imposes a civil penalty on service providers of $5,000 per user for violations of the ban, creating billions of dollars of potential legal exposure.
Executive orders cannot overturn laws enacted by Congress, and lawmakers have sued in the past to enforce laws they have passed. Legal experts said that even a hypothetical lawsuit from both houses of Congress could be a long shot, however, since courts might be inclined to see it as political question best left for the legislature, or a national security matter that falls under the White House's control.
The TikTok law does not lay out a right for private individuals to enforce it. But shareholders could sue service providers that cited Trump's order to ignore the ban.
"Shareholders of providers would have a valid case against companies that rely on the EO," said cybersecurity and digital privacy expert Timothy Edgar, who teaches at Brown University. "It's a huge gamble they are taking, given the extraordinary penalties the law provides."
REUTERS | Mike Scarcella
Editor’s Choice: The Trend of Many Countries Banning TikTok, What Do Experts Say?
Click here to get the latest news updates from Tempo on Google News
Who is Ross Ulbricht? The Silk Road Marketplace Creator Pardoned by Trump
25 menit lalu
As news about release of Ross Ulbricht broke internet, let's discuss Silk Road's founder identity, including his early life and endorsement from Trump
A Brief Look at Stargate, the US$500bn Investment in AI Infrastructure
55 menit lalu
Donald Trump announced a joint venture called Stargate intending to invest US$500 billion in AI infrastructure. Here's a closer look at Stargate.
Countries that Allow Dual Citizenship, Canada and U.S. Included
2 jam lalu
Find out countries that allow dual citizenship, including Canada and the U.S. Learn about the perks and drawbacks of dual nationality here.
Trudeau Says Canada Is Ready to Respond to Possible Trump Tariffs
2 jam lalu
Trump is expected to impose 25 percent duties on imports from Canada and Mexico.
UN Agencies Lament Trump's Day-One WHO Exit Order, Urge Reconsideration
3 jam lalu
UN agencies respond to U.S. President Donald Trump's executive order to end U.S. membership in the World Health Organization (WHO).
22 Democratic-led States Sue over Trump's Birthright Citizenship Order
4 jam lalu
Democratic-led states and civil rights groups filed lawsuits challenging Trump's bid to roll back birthright citizenship on Tuesday.
Netflix Shares Soar on Price Hikes and Record Subscriber Gains
7 jam lalu
Netflix (NFLX.O) reaffirmed its dominance of the streaming video market on Tuesday.
Germany to Lobby Trump on WHO Withdrawal, Agency Hopes for U-Turn
20 jam lalu
Germany is the second-largest national donor to the WHO, contributing around 3% of the agency's funding.
Today's Top 3 News: Donald Trump Sworn in a Second Time as U.S. President
20 jam lalu
Here is the list of the top 3 news on Tempo English today.
After Taking Office, Trump Pardons 1,500 Jan. 6 Defendants
21 jam lalu
Donald Trump pardoned about 1,500 of his supporters who attacked the U.S. Capitol four years ago.
